receiving compensation for injuries non-subscriber Companies
Share this post

What are the Challenges of Receiving Compensation for Injuries When Working for Non-subscriber Companies?

Key Points

  • Challenges of Non-Subscriber Compensation: Workers injured at non-subscriber companies must often undertake lengthy legal battles for compensation due to the absence of guaranteed benefits.
  • Proving Negligence: Unlike workers’ comp cases, injured employees at non-subscriber companies must prove employer negligence, requiring substantial evidence and facing defenses like preexisting condition claims.
  • Importance of Legal Representation: Hiring a personal injury lawyer can significantly improve the chances of securing fair compensation by gathering evidence, negotiating settlements, and handling legal complexities.

Sustaining an on-the-job injury can be hard enough on its own. Unfortunately, the situation gets even more complicated when your employer does not provide workers’ compensation insurance.

Without those guaranteed benefits in place, collecting fair payment for medical bills, lost income, and other accident-related costs often requires mounting a lengthy legal fight.

Understanding Workers’ Compensation and Why Some Employers Lack It

Workers’ compensation laws exist in all states and provide medical, rehabilitation, and wage replacement benefits to employees injured while performing job duties.

These no-fault systems were created to support recovery without workers having to sue employers and prove legal wrongdoing. So long as the injury occurred within the scope of employment, workers’ comp insurance pays for a portion of lost income and medical treatment regardless of what caused the accident.

But Texas does not require all employers to carry this form of insurance. It allows most companies to opt out, leaving the decision up to them. When businesses decide to go without it, they avoid paying premiums but take on full liability for covering worker injuries themselves.

While this may benefit their bottom line, it leaves employees in a precarious position if something does happen at work. Without guaranteed workers’ comp benefits as a safety net, securing rightful compensation from non-subscribers requires traversing a much more perilous path.

Why Pursuing Payment From Non-Subscribers Gets So Challenging

When a business tells an injured staff member “we do not carry workers’ compensation insurance,” it essentially means they must fend for themselves.

Without the no-fault concept to protect them, collecting medical and wage reimbursement involves either convincing the company to pay voluntarily or building a negligence case against them.

Unfortunately, employers and their insurance providers rarely make this process easy, creating numerous hurdles that can deny or limit how much injured professional receives. Here are some of the biggest complications workers face:

Burden of Proof Problems

The most frustrating roadblock is shouldering the burden of proof. Workers’ comp systems clearly lay out benefits and provide them without regard to fault.

But seeking the same recovery from a non-subscriber means proving the company did something wrong that directly caused your injuries.

Building a compelling negligence case requires substantial evidence to prove all the elements of negligence – like eyewitness testimony, video footage, expert analysis, and records definitively linking their safety violations to the accident. Gathering all this can be extremely difficult.

Preexisting Conditions Argued

Insurers defending non-subscriber cases also commonly claim the worker’s health issue or disability existed prior to the accident.

By arguing symptoms stem from a preexisting condition rather than the workplace incident itself, they aim to completely deny liability.

Having sound medical records and doctor statements connecting the injury directly to accident events helps dispute such allegations. However, providing unassailable proof still poses challenges.

Pressured to Accept Lowball Offers

Facing extensive medical debt and income losses quickly, injured staff may feel forced to accept meager out-of-court settlement offers just to stay financially afloat.

However, these payouts often grossly undervalue the long-term effects of the harm done.

While taking what is offered provides immediate relief, you may forfeit compensation that more fairly accounts for the true costs the injury will create down the road.

Limited Damages Available

Even if negligence is proven and the court awards damages, what the injured professional receives only covers economic losses tied specifically to the incident.

This typically includes medical expenses, lost wages, and sometimes rehabilitation costs.

But extra compensation for pain, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment, and other non-economic suffering is generally unavailable without workers’ comp in place. So

you may still end up substantially out-of-pocket despite winning your case.

Why Legal Representation is So Critical for Injured Staff

Why Legal Representation is So Critical for Injured Staff

Given the array of obstacles and frustration non-subscriber cases present, obtaining experienced legal help often proves essential.

Workers seriously injured at non-subscriber companies like Kroger having a knowledgeable personal injury attorney on their side can alleviate much of the burden and smooth the process of securing rightful compensation.

  • Assess Case Validity

The first thing counsel provides is an honest assessment of whether sufficient evidence exists to justify a lawsuit. If proving fault or causation seems doubtful, they will explain why negotiation or settlement may be the prudent route.

  • Gather Additional Evidence

If moving forward makes sense, the attorney utilizes investigators, experts, and other resources to develop evidence supporting your claim. This bolsters the case and counteracts defense arguments.

  • Document Financial Losses

They also ensure that documentation properly establishes the full scope of accident-related costs. This covers both expenses already incurred and future estimated costs. Thorough records make justifying compensation amounts easier.

  • Take Over Communications

Your lawyer fields inquiries from insurers, negotiates with adjusters, and interacts with the company’s legal team on your behalf. This greatly reduces the frustration of repeating your story and arguing every detail.

  • Determine Settlement Values

Based on their experience and case specifics, counsel can advise what a fair settlement offer looks like before agreeing to any proposal. This prevents prematurely accepting an amount that undervalues your losses.

  • File Suit If Necessary

If the company refuses reasonable negotiation attempts, the attorney will build a strong legal claim against them on your behalf. They handle everything from filing paperwork to arguing in court to facilitate appeals.

Having an expert personal injury lawyer in your corner levels the playing field, making it possible to successfully overcome the lack of insurance and other roadblocks non-subscriber cases create.

Key Times to Consider Hiring a Lawyer

Determining exactly when to involve an attorney varies case-by-case based on factors like injury severity, employer response, and financial urgency.

However, there are three general scenarios where legal help often proves extremely useful:

1. When the Company Denies Responsibility

As soon as the business or insurance provider disputes fault or indicates they will not cover accident-related costs, engaging counsel makes sense. Attorneys have the resources to establish liability and experience negotiating for full compensation when companies refuse to pay.

2. If You Cannot Work for Extended Timeframes

Sustaining injuries that require long recuperation periods typically rack up substantial medical bills and wage losses. With increased financial stakes due to prolonged unemployment, legal support helps maximize payouts to cover the heightened expenses.

3. If Communication Breaks Down

Frustrated exchanges with insurers or feeling forced into accepting undeservedly low settlement offers also signals hiring a lawyer. Their oversight of communications prevents manipulation and pushes negotiations in a fairer direction.

Do not wait until offers are made or the company files suit against you. Being proactive about legal representation prevents you from getting pressured into hasty decisions or giving up rights to compensation down the line.

Countering Company Tactics

Here are some tips from personal injury lawyers on responding to common insurance company tactics used to limit or deny claims:

  • Rushing Settlement Offers

Refuse to settle until fully informed on case value and do not let financial woes force your hand. Counsel ensures you understand short and long-term costs before negotiating so that early offers do not shortchange you.

  • Withholding Vital Information

Demand transparency upfront and have your attorney file motions to compel the release of documentation if met with resistance. Prolonged delays or ignoring requests warrants legal action.

  • Disputing Injury Causation

Supplying detailed medical records and doctor statements linking the accident to diagnosed conditions counters these allegations. Expert opinions and scientific analysis also help substantiate your stance.

  • Minimizing Injuries

Graphically detailing symptom severity and how disabilities limit regular activity challenges attempts to downplay conditions. Concrete examples resonate more than clinical descriptions with adjusters.

The bottom line is leveraging representation immediately to take control of the narrative before the company spins it to its advantage.

Partnering With a Lawyer For the Long Haul

The process of recovering damages from non-subscribers has the potential to grow highly frustrating and complex. Having an attorney assist you manages both legal and emotional stressors.

By being upfront about the details of your case and clearly communicating your needs, concerns, and limitations throughout the process, you enable counsel to build the strongest argument for maximum compensation. This requires dedicating time and effort to the process.

Though retaining a lawyer does not guarantee victory or a specific settlement amount, it does substantially improve your chances of receiving damages more aligned with the true costs the injury inflicts.

So, do not let employers take advantage of situations where they will not provide insurance. As an injured worker, you have every right to demand accountability and push for the fullest financial recovery possible.

Article by

Alla Levin

Seattle business and lifestyle content creator who can’t get enough of business innovations, arts, not ordinary people and adventures.

About Author

Alla Levin

Hi, I’m Alla, a Seattle business and lifestyle content creator who can’t get enough of business innovations, arts, not ordinary people and adventures. My mission is to help you grow in your creativity, travel the world, and live life to the absolute fullest!

movies for entrepreneurs

Boudoir photography allows women to celebrate their sensuality through graceful, intimate photographs...

I Recommend

All the information you need to understand the business world, your career, and marketing. All the information you need to understand the business world, your career, and marketing.

My favorite tools for creators

My favorite Tools for Content Creation

I recommend

Be Informed, Be Inspired - Join Today


Fact-checked with real-life-backed research

Written by small business experts and seasoned journalists

Updated to reflect the latest modern trends and advances

Reviewed by board-certified tech and lifestyle professionals