Where to Find the Tastiest Pizza in Staten Island and New Jersey

Written By Alla Levin
June 22, 2023

Are you looking for the best pizza joints in Staten Island and New Jersey? Look no further! Whether you prefer a classic Margherita or something more daring like BBQ Chicken Pizza, we’ve got you covered. Prepare to discover the top pizza places in the area and learn why they’re so beloved.

These hotspots offer some of the most mouth-watering pizza joints around, with crispy thin crusts and ooey-gooey melted cheese that will leave your taste buds begging for more.

With classic pepperoni and loaded veggie pies among the selections, there is something to satisfy everyone’s pizza craving. So why wait? Grab your appetite and indulge in the best pizza that Staten Island and New Jersey have to offer. Your taste buds will thank you!

Keep reading for the ultimate pizza adventure!

The Tastiest Pizza in Staten Island and New Jersey: Goodfella’s

If you’re looking for a slice of heaven in Staten Island, you can’t go wrong with Goodfellas. This pizza joint is the real deal – the sauce is tangy, the cheese is melty, and the crust has just the right amount of chew.

Honestly, I think it might be one of the best pies on the entire island. And the best part? It’s run by actual Goodfellas (the kind from the movies), so you can feel like a wise guy while you chow down on your slice. Just make sure not to mess with their recipe – you don’t want to end up sleeping with the fish.

Denino’s Pizzeria & TavernThe Tastiest Pizza in Staten Island and New Jersey

If you find yourself in Staten Island, try Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern. Since opening its doors in 1937, Denino’s has been serving up some of the best pizza in the city. Their classic Margherita pizza is a must-try, but if you’re feeling adventurous, go for their Spicy Chicken or White Pie. And if you’re not in the mood for pizza, their meatballs and chicken wings are also top-notch.

This pizza joint will take your taste buds on a ride you’ll never forget. The secret behind what makes Denino’s Pizza so delicious is no secret at all – it’s all in the sauce. The sauce is perfect – just the tanginess, sweetness, and a healthy dose of savory goodness.

The crust is crispy and thin, so you can focus on the delightful taste with every bite. And let’s not forget about the toppings – they use the freshest ingredients packed to the brim and will make every bite memorable. Next time you’re in the area, be sure to stop by Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern for a slice of heaven.

Joe’s Pizza

Located in Greenwich Village, Joe’s Pizza is a New York institution. The lines may be long, but the wait is well worth it. Founded in 1975, Joe’s has perfected the classic New York-style pizza. Their plain cheese slice is simple but delicious, and their white pizza with ricotta and mozzarella is a fan favorite.

Seriously, this place is the real deal regarding pizza in the Village. What sets Joe’s apart from the rest is the combination of crispy crusts and ooey-gooey cheese that’s just the right amount of greasy. Add a friendly atmosphere and affordable prices, and you’re a winner. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Joe’s will have you returning for more. Trust us; your taste buds will thank you.

Star Tavern

If you are in New Jersey, head to Star Tavern in Orange. Known for its thin-crust pizza, Star Tavern has been a neighborhood staple since 1945. Their Jersey-style tomato pie is a must-try, and their pepperoni pizza is a crowd-pleaser.

And if you’re looking for something different, their vodka sauce pizza is a unique and tasty option. Joshua Wood of Bloc, says, ‘Star Tavern’s vodka sauce pizza is an absolute dream – one of our favorites in Staten Island for sure.’

RazzaThe Tastiest Pizza in Staten Island and New Jersey

If you want a more upscale pizza experience, check out Razza in Jersey City. With a focus on using high-quality ingredients and traditional Neapolitan techniques, Razza’s pizza is a cut above the rest. Their Margherita pizza is a must-try, but don’t miss out on their Mushroom Pie or Clam Pie. And if you’re in the mood for something sweet, their Nutella dessert pizza is out of this world.

La Piazza

Are you craving the perfect slice of pizza in Staten Island? Look no further than La Piazza. For over 30 years, this family-owned pizzeria has been dishing out classic New York-style pies. Sink your teeth into their beloved Margherita pizza, or go for their delicious Sicilian pie. Are you feeling daring? Give their Chicken Marsala pizza a try, a delectable and one-of-a-kind option that will leave your tastebuds satisfied.

Their pies are exceptional, combining crispy, chewy crust and endless topping options. But what sets them apart is their one-of-a-kind sauce – a mystery blend of flavor that will leave you wanting more. Don’t settle for average – try La Piazza and treat your taste buds to the real deal.

Sal and Lloyd’s Pizza Place

All you Staten Island pizza lovers out there! If you haven’t tried Sal and Lloyd’s Pizza Place yet, you’re missing out on one of the best slices this borough offers. Seriously, their pies are almost too good to be true. Whether you’re a fan of classic Margherita or want to venture into specialty toppings (seriously, try the garlic knots), Sal and Lloyd’s has got you covered.

And don’t even get me started on the crust – it’s crispy yet chewy, with just the right amount of fluffiness. Believe me, folks, this is the real deal. If you’re looking for your new go-to pizza joint, look no further than Sal and Lloyd’s.

If you’re a pizza lover, you simply must try these top pizza places in Staten Island and New Jersey. From classic pies to unique flavor combinations, each restaurant offers something special. So grab a slice, dig in, and enjoy!

I Need More

Enter your Email Address to Join the
Gang of Curious and Life Loving

Related Articles